Review: We are the Goldens by Dana Reinhardt

Review: We are the Goldens by Dana Reinhardt

Review: We are the Goldens by Dana Reinhardt
We Are the Goldens by Dana Reinhardt

Genres: Young Adult
Published by Random House Children's Books
Publication Date: May 27th 2014
Pages: 208
Format: eBook
Buy the book: AmazonSmashwordsiTunes



"Reinhardt writes wonderfully about delicate, precarious human relationships, articulating dynamics I never noticed but which ring brilliantly true. The Goldens radiate charm, but beneath their charm is heartbreak, ambition, and delusion. There is so much to dissect and discuss here: this book will leave crowds of people eager to talk about the ending."--E. Lockhart, author of We Were Liars and The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau-Banks

Nell worships her older sister, Layla. They're one unit, intertwined: Nellayla. As Nell and her best friend, Felix, start their freshman year in high school, on Layla's turf, there's so much Nell looks forward to: Joining Layla on the varsity soccer team. Parties. Boys. Adventures.
But the year takes a very different turn.
Layla is changing, withdrawing. She's hiding something, and when Nell discovers what it is, and the consequences it might have, she struggles. She wants to support Layla, to be her confidante, to be the good sister she's always been. But with so much at stake, what secrets should she keep? What lies should she tell?
Award-winning young adult author Dana Reinhardt explores questions of loyalty, love, and betrayal in this provocative and intimate novel.

Line divider (pink)


I received this book for free from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.


I would have liked this book more if the author had chosen to tell the story differently. I don’t mean that I wish she had written a different story because this was a good idea for a book, I wish she had written this book in a different way.

The book is written as though Nell is writing a letter to her older sister Layla. The overall tone of the letter is an apology, and we don’t find out what Layla is apologizing for until the very end of the book.


While reading, I kept wondering why Nell was describing these details and telling Layla things that she already knew. She would say things that were important for the reader to know, but most of the time she was talking about conversations that she had with her sister so why would she have to tell her sister about those conversations in the letter. It was weird. The language was stilted and awkward, and Nell used words that no 15-year-old girl would use in a letter to their sister.


The way the book was written may have taken away from  my enjoyment, but this actually wasn’t a badly book. I can tell tell the author is talented and has a love of words. Nell is a pretty cool girl, even though she is way too serious for her age and over thinks everything. Her high-strung attitude and desire to fix things for other people reminds me a lot of myself when I was her age, and I think she is a character who is easy to identify with.

I only got to know Layla through Nell’s eyes, but she seemed like a great girl too. Or at least she was great before she entered into a relationship with her teacher.

Nell finds out about this affair and spends the entire book agonizing over what to do. She idolizes her big sister and they are very close. She doesn’t want to do anything that would push her away or get Layla in trouble, but she knows that what their teacher is doing is wrong. She also knows that the person her sister is becoming because of the affair is not a healthy person. The affair is turning her into a desperate and scary version of herself, and Nell just wants her sister back.


Nell doesn’t spend the entire letter talking about her sister, she spends time talking about herself and the things she is going through. It is through the portions of the letter that weren’t devoted to Layla, that I got to know my favorite person in this book, Felix.

Felix is Nell’s best friend, and they have an awesome relationship. He is funny, charming, cute, and has that “best friend radar” that helps him know just the right thing to do or say when Nell needs him. They cuddle and give each other a hard time, and I kept wondering why this girl wasn’t crazy in love with this kid! He literally told her over and over that he loved her and she was the only girl for him. I think everyone but Nell knew that when he said these things, he meant them, but Nell’s obliviousness to Felix’s feelings for her, just enhanced the cuteness.


I may not have connected with the way this story was told, but because I can tell that the author has talent I will be reading more of her work in the future. She took a risk with the way she wrote this book, and I respect that. And I also really liked the characters.

Because of mature subject matter, I would recommend this book for ages 15 and up.

Three Roses

One StarOne StarOne Star

GR Button

Line divider (pink)

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Subscribe to get notifications of future events, post, and giveaways!

Sharing is caring!

2 thoughts on “Review: We are the Goldens by Dana Reinhardt

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *